Florida’s Best Homemade Ice Cream

All of our Big Olaf Ice Creams are hand mixed by local Amish craftsmen and churned in batch freezers. Our Lickity Splits Ice Cream and Mateo’s Italian Ices are made from quality all-natural ingredients, locally sourcing products whenever possible, and many of our ice cream inclusions are made from scratch in their facility. Our goal at Island Scoops is to continue to provide the best of the best. Locals and vacationers return year after year to enjoy Florida’s best homemade Ice Cream.

If you need a copy to download or print please visit our Menu page at https://islandscoops.shop/downloadable-menu/

Sundaes Small $5.75 / Large $4.25
Classic Sundae 

Vanilla Ice Cream, drizzled with hot fudge, whip cream, & sprinkled with nuts & cherry.

Traditional Banana Split 

1 scoop each of chocolate, vanilla, strawberry ice cream drizzled with pineapple, strawberry, & chocolate sauce, whip cream, & sprinkled with nuts & cherry.

Build Your Banana Split 

3 scoops of ice cream drizzled with 3 sauces, whip cream, & sprinkled with nuts & cherry

Tin Roof 

Vanilla ice cream drizzled with hot fudge & sprinkled with Spanish peanuts


Vanilla ice cream drizzled with hot fudge & caramel, sprinkled with Pecans

Rocky Road 

Chocolate ice cream drizzled with hot fudge & sprinkled with mini marshmallows & nuts

Brownie $6.95 

A warm chocolate brownie topped with 2 scoops of vanilla ice cream, drizzled with chocolate sauce & chocolate sprinkles

Cooke Ice Cream Sandwich $5.75 

1 scoop of ice cream sandwiched between 2 fresh baked cookies & rolled in rainbow sprinkles

Fresh Baked Cookies $1.50

Rotating Flavors include M&M Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip and Double Chocolate Chip

Cupcakes $2.25

Rotating Flavors include Chocolate, Strawberry, Vanilla, and Key Lime

Pies $4.00

Rotating Flavors include Key Lime, Nutella, Chocolate Silk, Peanut Butter, Banana, and Coconut Cream Pie

Cheesecakes $4.50

Rotating Flavors include Cookies & Cream, Key Lime, and Turtle

Cakes $4.50

Rotating Flavors include Coconut Key Lime and Chocolate Kahlua

Tarts $4.00

Rotating Flavors include Cheesecake, Peanut Butter, Key Lime, Banana, Nutella, Chocolate Silk, and Coconut Key Lime

Pecan Pie Bars $3.25
Brownies $2.25
Chocolate Keylime on a Stick $4.50

Kiddie Size – 1 Scoop

Bowl, Cake or Sugar Cone $2.95

Dipped Cake or Dipped Sugar Cone $3.95

Small Size – 2 Scoops

Bowl, Cake or Sugar Cone $3.95

Dipped Cake or Dipped Sugar Cone $4.95

Waffle Bowl or Waffle Cone $4.95

Dipped Waffle Bowl or Dipped Waffle Cone $5.95

Large Size – 3 Scoops

Bowl, Cake or Sugar Cone $5.95

Dipped Cake or Dipped Sugar Cone $6.95

Waffle Bowl or Waffle Cone $6.95

Dipped Waffle Bowl or Dipped Waffle Cone $7.95

Pints $7.95 
Quarts $10.95
Toppings $0.95



Milkshakes & Malts – $6.95

Strawberry Banana

Cookies & Cream

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Mint Chocolate Chip

Classic Chocolate, Vanilla, or Strawberry

Design Your Own – Choose from any available flavor
Available Toppings: Whip Cream & Cherry $0.95
Include Crushed Cookies or Candy $0.95
Floats – $6.50

Sprecher Root Beer

Cherry Cola

Orange Creamsicle

Cream Soda


Frozen Bananas $4.25

Choose From: Chocolate, Sprinkled, Peanut, and Coconut

Lickity Split On A Stick Popcraft Popsicles $3.50

Choose from a variety of flavors

Bottled Water $1.00
Vintage Bottled Soda $2.50

Rotating Available Flavors include Dogs N’ Suds Root Beer, Frosties Blue Cream Soda, Cheer Wine, Ne Hi Grape, and more

Featuring Big Olaf & Lickity Splits Ice Cream

Amaretto Almond


Black Cherry

Birthday Cake

Blue Moon

Butter Pecan


Chocolate Almond

Chocolate Chip

Chocolate Lovers

Chocolate Peanut Butter


Coconut Almond Joy


Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Cookies & Cream

Dutch Peanut Butter

Heath Bar

Kahlua Krunch

Mint Chip

Peanut Butter Cup


Plantation Praline

Rocky Road

Rum Raisin



Super Man

Trash Can



Featuring Big Olaf & Lickity Splits Ice Cream

Brownie Fudge

Bubble Gum

Black Raspberry

Blueberry Cheesecake


Captain Butterscotch

Caramel Explosion

Cookie Monster

Cotton Candy

Gator Tracks

Key Lime Cheesecake

Lemon Blueberry

Maple Walnut


Orange Creamsicle


Raspberry Cheesecake

Root Beer Swirl

Royal Banana Crunch

Salted Caramel Pretzel

Salted Caramel Truffle

Strawberry Cheesecake

Strawberry Rose

White Chocolate Raspberry


Featuring Big Olaf & Lickity Splits Ice Cream & Mateo’s Italian Ice
Dairy Free House Flavors


Dairy Free Rotating Flavors


Pina Colada

Blue Raspberry

Sugar Free House Flavor

Butter Pecan

Sugar Free Rotating Flavors




Sauces $0.95




Hot Fudge


Pureed Strawberries


Pureed Pineapple

Toppings $0.95

Chocolate Sprinkles

Crushed Oreos

Gummy Candies

Maraschino Cherries

Mini Marshmallows



Rainbow Sprinkles

Reese Pieces

Slivered Almonds

Spanish Peanuts

Sour Gummy Candy

Whip Cream


Delivery Service for Island Scoops is now available through Island Eats Delivery Service on Anna Maria Island and the Historic Cortez Fishing Village.  For more information and to place an order please visit https://www.islandeats.net/islandscoops

Use Discount Code SCOOPS for Special Savings on your first order!

Visit Us

103B Gulf Drive North

Bradenton Beach

FL 34217

Contact us

(941) 840-0095



Open Hours

M-F: 1pm – 10pm

Sat: 1pm – 10pm

Sun: 1pm – 10pm